I sent this link to people on my email list:
http://www.city-journal.org/html/14_1_the_illegal_alien.html
Not only did some of them yell at me because the article was too long, but several of them actually thought I was wasting their time by sending them "unimportant" clutter in their mailbox. That kind of stumped me. I was under the impression that things that happen in our country are of concern to us all because this is a government of the people, by the people, and for the people (it's called a Dem-ahhhh-cracy, boys and girls.) As such, everyone should be concerned with the issues that affect the way our country is run.
Sometimes I get to the point where I start to argue myself into a corner and I switch sides mid-stream; the issue of Immigration is one such case, as you will see if you continue...
After reading the article that I linked above, a friend of mine sent me the following question:
I read that article about Illegal Immigrants..I wonder if they don't just keep letting those degenerates in because they vote? Do they vote? I am not sure about that? I guess if they are illegal then they don't..but I cannot figure out why we keep letting them in ... are we that afraid of them? I never realized this was as big a problem as it is..
My responses follow (this is where you see my circular logic):
The first problem is whether we can legally deport them due to claims of asylum (ie, the "you can't send me back because they will kill me! You have to offer me shelter here!" defense.) We have a legal system that will represent anyone, no matter what they have done. This further slows matters, allowing illegals to stay here for years while their "case" is tied up in the legal red tape. Meanwhile, they are still living here, collecting welfare, foodstamps, holding down jobs, getting free medication/healthcare ... all courtesy of the taxpayers.
Unfortunately, nationality of the illegal also plays a big part, depending on the area of the country they are squatting in: If you are an illegal of hispanic background living in Texas, forget it, the authorities can't touch you. If you are cuban, living in Florida, same thing. If you are Saudi, living in New York, from the tone of the article, same thing again, they can't touch you.
Speaking of Florida, here is a case in point: A thriving group of people are living in Floriday, are naturalized citizens of the United States ... they chose to move here, adopt this country, make their living here (in a few cases in particular have done extremely well for themselves, too) have raised their families in the United States ... They brought their own culture, customs and beliefs with them when they moved here. Basically, they uprooted their whole neighborhood and replanted it on US soil. A classic melting pot situation, right? Wrong.
A melting pot implies that cultures mesh, joining to form a richer people with a greater diversity. Instead, we have an ethnocentric group who have squatted in the middle of
this area in Florida and continued to import family members (illegals) to join them here, until they have become a population to be reckoned with ... their dense numbers, demographically, makes them important as consumers (product placement and marketing has now switched to spanish/english instructions and packaging), and they are also attractive as constituents.
Our governing officials are voted into office by a representative faction of the populace ... they know if there is a large Hispanic population they have to make sure the issues they tackle don't offend anyone of that persuasion because otherwise the popularity of this governing official will become a casualty. They don't want to offend voters or tackle causes dear to the hearts of the majority of a group of people.
As for the quote in the article that says illegals are changing our language --- this group in Florida prides themselves on never having learned to speak English, and don't feel they should have to. They are forcing the english speaking Florida natives out of their neighborhoods (not by strong arm techniques ... people are leaving because they don't like to see what is happening to their neighborhood, that they have become foreigners in their own neighborhood and home no longer feels like home.) The local merchants must cater to the hispanics (and largely illegal population), rather than the English speaking minority who remain. These same non-english speaking people are lobbying to have the official language of the United States changed to spanish.
If this comes to the political forefront then you will see me become a political activist.
I don't want you to think I don't like people who come from another country ... not at all! What I don't like are people who come from another country, choose to LIVE HERE (as in become a citizen) and don't do a damn thing to learn the language, the customs, etc. And what I REALLY DON'T LIKE is how we are ENCOURAGING that by printing everything in English and Spanish.
I can speak a teensy bit of Spanish and always swore I was going to brush up to get
better (I have a good accent, I've been told, sound like a native,
hay carumba!) but choose not to, on principle, because I am so disgusted with how EVERYTHING is becoming more Spanish, instead of immigrants becoming more familiar with the language of their adopted country.
I don't think it really started to bother me until an extra button was added on to the ATM machine at my bank ... forcing me to choose my transaction in English or Spanish, thereby lengthening the time that it now takes to process a transaction at the supposedly rapid cash dispensing ATM's. I kind of think if you want your money bad enough, you will figure it out.
After I read this article yesterday, I kept thinking about it.
I am interested in Genealogy and recently I found the records of an immigrant ancestor at the National Archives. He came here from Ireland or England (still not sure which because he was either illiterate or trying to lie) but his last name was Farrell, so my guess is he had some Irish somewhere in his background. He arrived in the early 1800's, well before the potato famine started forcing the Irish people to emigrate in droves ... my point (and I do have one) is this:
I know that the Irish were despised and hated, as were the Chinese who settled in California during the Gold Rush. Is this struggle with the immigrant hispanic population just the newest version of history repeating itself?
(I know I have singled out hispanics ... this is because they are the largest immigrant population in America, and the one having the biggest impact, but my question refers to all immigrant nationalities .)
The Irish and the Chinese who came here during the 1800's were looking to better their lives. Isn't the same true for the immigrants of today? How about the criminal element? I'm sure they came over in the 1800's too, drawn by the wildness of the West and the riches of the gold rush ... of course, back then vigilantism was the way to handle anyone who took criminal behavior too far. Of course, our country was so wild then we probably classified as a 3rd world country by today's standards. Today we have the police, the INS and Dept. of Homeland Security ... and Lawyers. So that means that the ongoing battle between law enforcement officials and lawyers is merely the result of a civilized society, right?
So ... back to the question of illegals and what to do with them:
Do they have a right to try to make a better world for themselves? Yes, they do.
So how does one do that properly? One applies for a VISA (and then gets an American Express and Mastercard ... heee-heee!) and permission to enter. If you are from one of the "blacklisted" countries (hostile to USA), you will be denied a VISA.
(The blacklisted countries are those countries that encourage you to sacrifice a child for the cause, "blow up a baby to show you hate the USA" ... I happen to agree with John Walsh from "America's Most Wanted" and his well-expressed views on the home grown loonies we have here already, and I see nothing wrong with denying entrance to the foreign grown loonies.)
I'm now arguing myself into a corner, and I'm rapidly losing my point, so I'm going to finish with this:
Basically, I love this country. I think this is the best place on earth to live and it's a privilege to live here. I want to make sure that everyone who comes here feels the same, because if you don't then get out. But, how do you enforce this? By closing the borders? Sealing ourselves in like China with their great wall? Berlin with theirs? I don't think we want to become like either of those examples, so how do we solve the issue of uncontrolled immigration, and what do we do with those who are already here, as well as those still trying to get in? If you know the answers please write to me and we can forward a few letters to President Bush, the INS and Dept. of Homeland Security because I think they need some suggestions on how to properly deal with such a troublesome issue.
(Sharondarella steps down off her soapbox and everyone claps because they are all really glad she is done talking.)
:)